The Bukhtarma Old Believers as an Ethnoconfessional Group in the USSR in the Post-Soviet Russian Historiography
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.69567/3007-0236.2023.3.389.406Keywords:
post-Soviet historiography, historiography of the history of the Old Believers, Soviet anti-religious policy, anti-religious repression, Old Believers of the Soviet period, Bukhtarma Old Believers, Old Believers of QazaqstanAbstract
In the study, using the comparative historical method, the post-Soviet historiography of the history of the Bukhtarma Old Believers is studied. The author studies Russian post-Soviet historiography and Qazaq post-Soviet Russian-language historiography. The most important scientific problems and approaches to the study of the history of the Old Believers are highlighted and compared. The article contributes to the discussion of why it is necessary to jointly study the achievements of both Russian and Qazaq post-Soviet historiography. The author reveals the expansion of the modern ethnographic framework in the study of the Bukhtarma Old Believers. The problem of the identification of the Bukhtarma Old Believers in modern historical literature is revealed. The author notes that in the last decade, new studies have appeared in which the Bukhtarma Old Believers are identified with the Old Believers of Altai. Modern Russian and Qazaq historians systematically turn to Soviet historiography. Soviet historical studies written in the 1920s and 1930s act as a historical source. The author analyzes the historiography of the most important problems in the history of the Bukhtarma Old Believers. The most significant problems are Soviet repression, preservation of identity, and preservation of traditionalism. The historiography presents case studies on selected issues related to common scientific problems. The author concludes that the historiography of modern Bukhtarma Old Believers can successfully develop as a single “post-Soviet Russian-language historiography.” National historiography is inferior in depth to scientific analysis.
References
Ageeva, E.A. 2016. Staroobriadchestvo iuga Rossii: tserkovno bytovye traditsii i knizhnost [Old Believers in the south of Russia: church and everyday traditions and bookishness]. In: Bogosluzhebnye praktiki i kultovye iskusstva v polietnicheskom regione [Liturgical practices and religious arts in a multi-ethnic region]. Maikop: Magarin, 34–59 (in Russian).
Alpyspaeva, G.A. 2022. Sovetskaia vlast i sektantskie religioznye obshchiny v Kazakhstane v 1920–1930-e gg. [Soviet power and sectarian religious communities in Qazaqstan in the 1920s–1930s.]. In: Aktualnye problemy gumanitarnykh i sotsialno-ekonomicheskikh nauk [Current problems of the humanities and socio-economic sciences], 1 (84), 20–27 (in Russian).
Avdeeva, V.I. 2018. Bukhtarminskie kamenshchiki – staroobriadtsy Altaia [Bukhtarma masons - Old Believers of Altai]. In: Iskusstvo glazami molodykh [Art through the eyes of the young]. Krasnoyarsk: Hvorostovsky Siberian State Institute of Arts, 285–287 (in Russian).
Badenkov, Iu.P. 2021. Zhizn v gorakh po kanonam very i kulturnogo naslediia [Life in the mountains according to the canons of faith and cultural heritage]. In: Voprosy geografii [Questions of geography], 153, 90–113. DOI 10.24057/probl.geogr.153.5 (in Russian).
Bogochanova, A.V. 2020. Opyt interpretatsii etnograficheskogo naslediia v Sovetskoi Rossii v 1920-e gg. [Experience of interpretation of ethnographic heritage in Soviet Russia in the 1920s]. In : Uchenye zapiski (Altaiskaia gosudarstvennaia akademiia kultury i iskusstv) [Scientific notes (Altai State Academy of Culture and Arts)], 4 (26), 28–33. DOI 10.32340/2414-9101-2020-4-28-33 (in Russian).
Danilko, E.S. 2019. Smert blizhe rubashki: pokhoronnaia obriadnost staroobriadtsev-chasovennykh [Death is closer than the shirt: funeral rites of the Old Believers-chapels]. In: Novye issledovaniia Tuvy [New studies of Tuva], 1, 4. DOI 10.25178/nit.2019.1.4 (in Russian).
Ilin, V.N. 2019. Staroobriadchestvo Altaia v kontekste repressivnoi politiki imperskikh vlastei [Old Believers of Altai in the context of the repressive policies of the imperial authorities]. In: Narody i religii Evrazii [Peoples and religions of Eurasia], 4 (21), 105–114. DOI 10.14258/nreur(2019)4-08 (in Russian).
Kazhenova, G.T. 2018. Religioznaia zhizn katolicheskikh obshchin Kazakhstana v usloviiakh antireligioznoi politiki sovetskogo rezhima [Religious life of Catholic communities in Kazakhstan in the conditions of the anti-religious policy of the Soviet regime]. In: Vestnik Evraziiskogo natsionalnogo universiteta im. L.N. Gumileva. Seriia: Istoricheskie nauki. Filosofiia. Religiovedenie [Bulletin of the L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University. Series: Historical Sciences. Philosophy. Religious Studies], 3 (124), 31–43. DOI 10.32523/2616-7255-2018-124-3-31-43 (in Russian).
Khirianova, L.V. 2009. Traditsionnye osnovy semi kak glavnyi faktor formirovaniia identichnosti staroobriadchestva v epokhu modernizatsii [Traditional foundations of the family as the main factor in the formation of the identity of the Old Believers in the era of modernization]. In: Analitika kulturologii [Analytics of cultural studies], 1 (13), 173–178 (in Russian).
Koliaskina, E.A. 2015. Krasnyi ugol / babia kut: gendernaia semantika prostranstva u russkikh starozhilov i pereselentsev Altaia vo vtoroi polovine 19 – pervoi polovine 20 veka [Red corner / woman's kut: gender semantics of space among Russian old-timers and settlers of Altai in the second half of the 19th - first half of the 20th century]. In: Etnografiia Altaia i sopredelnykh territorii [Ethnography of Altai and adjacent territories], Vol. 9. Barnaul: Altai State Pedagogical Academy, 111–118 (in Russian).
Kupriianova, I.V. 2012. Likvidatsiia staroobriadcheskikh obshchin Altaia v kontse 1920-kh – seredine 1930-kh gg. [Liquidation of Old Believer communities in Altai in the late 1920s – mid-1930s]. In: Mir nauki, kultury, obrazovaniia [World of science, culture, education], 5 (36), 197–202 (in Russian).
Kupriianova, I.V. 2013. Bespopovskie staroobriadcheskie konfessii Altaia na rubezhe XIX–XX vv. [Bespopovsky Old Believer confessions of Altai at the turn of the 19th–20th centuries]. In: Mir nauki, kultury, obrazovaniia [World of Science, Culture, Education], 6 (43), 452–456 (in Russian).
Kupriianova, I.V. 2015. Religioznaia situatsiia v srede staroobriadtsev Uimona v XX – nachale XXI v. [The religious situation among the Old Believers of Uimon in the 20th – early 21st centuries]. In: Etnografiia Altaia i sopredelnykh territorii [Ethnography of Altai and adjacent territories]. Vol. 9. Barnaul: Altai State Pedagogical Academy, 128–131 (in Russian).
Kupriianova, I.V. 2019. Vzaimodeistvie russkikh staroobriadtsev s aborigenami Altaia kak kolonizatsionnyi resurs [Interaction of Russian Old Believers with the aborigines of Altai as a colonization resource]. In: Uchenye zapiski (Altaiskaia gosudarstvennaia akademiia kultury i iskusstv) [Scientific notes (Altai State Academy of Culture and Arts)], 2 (20), 78–82. DOI 10.32340/2414-9101-2019-2-77-81 (in Russian).
Kupriianova, I.V. 2020. Vozmozhnosti ispolzovaniia kulturno-istoricheskogo naslediia staroobriadchestva v sfere turizma [Possibilities of using the cultural and historical heritage of the Old Believers in the field of tourism]. In: Kraevedenie i turizm [Local history and tourism]. Vol. 2. Barnaul: Altai State Pedagogical University, 265–274 (Russian).
Latyshev, K.A. 2021. Istoriografiia politiki Sovetskogo gosudarstva 1929–1939 gg. v otnoshenii staroobriadchestva [Historiography of the policy of the Soviet state in 1929–1939. in relation to the Old Believers]. In: Zhurnal Belorusskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istoriia [Journal of the Belarusian State University. Story], 2, 74–84 (in Russian).
Likhachev, E. 2021. Krestianskie khoziaistva Bukhtarminskikh staroobriadtsev [Peasant farms of the Bukhtarma Old Believers]. In: Proekt Baikal [Project Baikal], 18 (67), 157–162. DOI 10.51461/projectbaikal.67.1771 (in Russian).
Matytsin, K.S. 2018. K voprosu ob identifikatsii altaiskikh «kamenshchikov» [On the issue of identifying Altai “masons”]. In: Trudy molodykh uchenykh Altaiskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Proceedings of young scientists Altai State University], 15, 222–224 (in Russian).
Matytsin, K.S. 2018a. Legenda o Belovode kak faktor migratsii staroobriadtsev v otechestvennoi istoriografii [The legend of Belovodye as a factor in the migration of Old Believers in domestic historiography]. In: Trudy IV Kongressa rossiiskikh issledovatelei religii [Proceedings of the IV Congress of Russian Researchers of Religion]. Blagoveshchensk: Amur State University, 389–395 (in Russian).
Matytsin, K.S. 2019. Vzaimodeistvie altaiskikh «kamenshchikov» s korennym naseleniem Altaia: kratkii istoriograficheskii obzor [Interaction of Altai “masons” with the indigenous population of Altai: a brief historiographical review]. In: Materialy Pervogo altaisticheskogo foruma [Materials of the First Altaic Forum]. Barnaul; Gorno-Altaisk: Altai State University, 165–167 (in Russian).
Mukaeva, L.N. 2001. Etnosotsialnaia kharakteristika staroobriadtsev Iuzhnogo Altaia [Ethnosocial characteristics of the Old Believers of Southern Altai]. In: Etnografiia Altaia i sopredelnykh territorii [Ethnography of Altai and adjacent territories]. Barnaul: Altai State Pedagogical Academy, 265–267 (in Russian).
Pokrovskii, N.N. 2020. Osvoenie Sibiri i staroobriadchestvo [Development of Siberia and Old Believers]. In: Kontinent Sibir [Continent of Siberia]. Novosibirsk: Institute of Economics and Organization of Industrial Production SB RAS, 30–47 (in Russian).
Razdykov, S.Z., Abdrahmanov, B.N., Ajtkenov, Z.Sh. 2018. Semejnyj uklad staroverov Vostochnogo Kazahstana [Family life of the Old Believers of Eastern Qazaqstan]. In: Vestnik Evrazijskogo nacional'nogo universiteta im. L.N. Gumileva. Serija: Istoricheskie nauki. Filosofija. Religiovedenie [Bulletin of the L.N. Gumilyov Eurasian National University. Series: Historical Sciences. Philosophy. Religious Studies], 4 (125), 71–79. DOI 10.32523/2616-7255-2018-125-4-71-79 (in Russian).
Rovnova, O.G, Savinov D.M. 2017. Sootnoshenie dialektnykh chert pervichnogo i vtorichnogo govora (staroobriadtsy kamenshchiki» Kazakhstanskogo Altaia i «Sintsziantsy» Iuzhnoi Ameriki) [Correlation of dialectal features of the primary and secondary dialect (Old Believers - “masons” of the Kazakhstan Altai and “Xinjiang” of South America)]. In: Trudy instituta russkogo iazyka im. V.V. Vinogradova [Proceedings of the V.V. Vinogradov Russian Language Institute], 12, 320–333 (in Russian).
Rubleva, A.A. 2022. Potomki staroobriadtsev derevni Makurino: praktika sokhraneniia identichnosti (po materialam polevykh issledovanii 2022 goda) [Descendants of the Old Believers of the village of Makurino: the practice of preserving identity (based on field research in 2022)]. In: Problemy arkheologii, etnografii, antropologii Sibiri i sopredelnykh territorii [Problems of archeology, ethnography, anthropology of Siberia and adjacent territories], 28, 921–926. DOI 10.17746/2658-6193.2022.28.0921-0926 (in Russian).
Shitova, N.I. 2018.Staroobriadcheskie gruppy v Gornom Altae (po polevym materialam) [Old Believer groups in the Altai Mountains (based on field materials)]. In: Polevye issledovaniia na Altae, v Priirtyshe i Verkhnem Priobe (arkheologiia, etnografiia, ustnaia istoriia) [Field research in Altai, the Irtysh region and the Upper Ob region (archaeology, ethnography, oral history)]. Vol. 13. Gorno-Altaisk: Gorno-Altaisk State University, 312–317 (in Russian).
Zhanbosinova, A.S. 2011. Gosudarstvo i religiia – religiia i gosudarstvo: politika protivostoianiia [State and religion – religion and state: politics of confrontation]. In: Religiia v istorii narodov Rossii i Tsentralnoi Azii [Religion in the history of the peoples of Russia and Central Asia]. Barnaul: Altai University, 21–26 (in Russian).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Kiryl A. Latyshau
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
